Update: got stuck choosing between a winch and lockers before Moab, and my buddy's comment still haunts me
Had $1,200 saved up for one upgrade before a trip to Moab last spring, and I sat in my driveway for a week going back and forth between a winch and a rear locker. Ended up going with the locker since my buddy Dave kept saying "you can't lock a winch," and sure enough I buried it to the axles in sand on day two with nothing to pull myself out. Now I'm second guessing if lockers were really the smart pick for mixed terrain or if I just got lucky the rest of the trip, what would you have grabbed first?