Took me 11 days to figure out the faint marks on a potsherd were shell temper, not cracks
Back in March I dug up a soapy little sherd from a site outside Athens, Georgia, and spent 11 days squinting at these thin white lines under a loupe, convinced the thing was cracked and ready to crumble. Turned out a retired ceramist at our local society meeting took one look and said that's crushed mussel shell mixed into the clay, which was how people down here made pots hold up to cooking. How do you all tell temper apart from natural wear when the surface is this worn down?
Wet the surface first, a cracked sherd will pull water into the crack line while shell bits stay dull and matte. Learned that one after wasting a whole afternoon on a Woodland piece down in Oconee County. The light angle trick helps too, tilt it slow and shell temper glints flat while cracks show shadow.