Rolled tube sheet vs. stayed tube sheet on a 500 hp boiler, and my pick split the crew
Last month we retubed a 500 hp firetube in Gary, Indiana, and the crew argued for two days over pinned and rolled versus welded and stayed. I went with rolled and beveled, mostly because the customer wanted to stay under a $40k budget and we could do it with our own guys instead of calling in a welder. We wrapped it in nine days with no leaks on hydro, but the old hand on the job said welded stays would outlast my grandkids. Now I'm second guessing whether I traded long term life for short term money. What do you all run on a boiler this size, and does the service really tell the story?
Watched a buddy go through this exact fight on a 400 hp unit down in Hammond. He went welded and stayed, spent the extra eight grand, and had to bring in a certified guy from outside. Two years later they pulled the front door for inspection and the stay welds looked brand new, no weeping, nothing. But he told me the real kicker was the schedule, they lost four extra days waiting on that welder to show up. Made me wonder if the downtime cost more than the weld did. Your nine days with no leaks sounds like a win to me, budget and all.