Frozen tamales beat the fresh ones at the mercado and I'll die on this hill
Everybody at the Saturday market in Phoenix keeps pushing me toward the fresh tamales from the lady with the big steam pot, but I actually like the frozen ones better. I tried both on the same day back in March, a dozen fresh for $18 and a bag of frozen for $11, and the frozen ones held their shape way better and didn't turn to mush on me. The fresh ones were good for the first bite and then fell apart, so I ended up eating them with a fork out of the pot like a sad soup. I know that's basically food heresy around here, but the masa texture matters more to me than the idea of fresh. Also I can keep a bag in the freezer for a month and pull out two when I want them, which the fresh ones will not do. What am I missing here, do I just not know a good fresh tamale when I taste one?
Are you sure the fresh ones you got were actually made that morning? Because a real fresh tamale from a good steam pot shouldn't fall apart like that. The masa gets soft when it sits in a cooler or gets reheated too many times, which is probably what happened if she's selling them late in the day. My abuela's rule was to check the husk, if it peels off clean and the masa holds the shape of the husk, it's right, and if it sticks and smears, it sat too long. Frozen ones hold up because they're par-cooked and chilled fast, but that's also why the masa tastes a little flat to me. So you're not wrong about texture, you just might be comparing fresh tamales to frozen ones that were actually fresher.