Warning: I mortared my first chimney crown with a trowel and it cracked by November
Switched to a rubber float and a 3/4 inch rod after a guy in Tulsa told me a trowel packs it too tight and it blows out over winter. Anyone else learn crowns the hard way or am I the only one?
Something folks forget is the mix itself does half the cracking before your tool even touches it. A crown is basically a sloped slab with no room to move, so if the mud is a touch wet and you finish it smooth with steel you seal the surface and trap water right as the cold comes. The trowel tightens the top and leaves the weak stuff under it, then the freeze pops it. I've seen guys do great work with a trowel and a stiff mix and still get a hairline crack because they skipped a control joint or let the sun hit it too fast. So the float and rod trick works, no doubt, but it's really about not overworking the face and giving it somewhere to crack on purpose.