I thought the cash envelope thing was silly until my grocery money actually lasted the whole month
Six months ago my sister in law handed me a stack of plain envelopes and told me to try the cash thing, and I smiled and put them in a drawer. I figured why would pulling out cash work any better than just watching my app, I'm not a kid. Then in March I noticed I was hitting the grocery store 4 or 5 times a week and dropping $30 here and $18 there, and my card total was $610 for the month with nothing to show for it. So I pulled $140 out for groceries, split it into two weeks, and told myself when the envelope was empty that was it. The first week I got down to $9 left and had to stand in the cereal aisle doing math on my phone, and it stung, but I walked out with just the store brand oats and a carton of eggs. End of April my total was $355. I'm not saying it fixes everything, but seeing the cash get thin is way harder to ignore than a little number on a screen. Has anyone tried the envelope thing for gas or is that too much of a hassle?
My buddy Dave tried the gas envelope for two months and gave up around week six, said he kept forgetting to swing by the bank before his tank hit empty. What he does now is pull $60 out every other Friday and that's his gas till the next paycheck. He says it works fine as long as he fills up on the way home from the bank, not three days later.