Dropped $340 on a dovetail jig before learning the old pin-and-tails method by hand, and I still can't decide
So about 8 months back I got it in my head that I needed a dovetail jig to speed up drawer boxes, and I dropped $340 on one with the whole template kit. Used it on maybe 5 drawers and fought the setup every time, the bit wandered, and I burned two maple sides bad enough to scrap them. Then a retired guy named Walt who does repair work out of his garage over in Lansing showed me how he cuts tails by hand with a marking gauge and a thin saw, and honestly the guy is faster than my jig was. Now I'm stuck in this spot where I can't tell if the jig was a waste of money or if I just never learned to set it right, and I keep going back and forth. Half of me says the jig pays for itself once you get the hang of it, the other half says hand cut joints are quieter, cheaper, and I actually enjoy them. My wife says sell the jig, Walt says keep it for production runs, and I'm just sitting here with $340 of aluminum and a bruised ego. Any of you run a jig for everyday boxes or have you gone back to hand cut tails?