Shoutout to the dispatcher in Reno who talked me out of the cheap open carrier
Last spring I had to get my grandma's old Camry from Reno down to my place in Phoenix, and I was stuck between two quotes. The cheap one was an open carrier at $650 with a pickup window of "sometime next week," and the other was an enclosed hauler at $1,100 that could grab it that Friday. I almost went with the cheap one to save the money, but the dispatcher asked me one thing, whether the car had ever been repainted, and when I said the hood was done about 10 years back, he said flat out that a rock chip on fresh paint is a headache nobody needs. So I paid the extra $450 and went enclosed. The car showed up spotless, and about a month later I saw a post from a guy whose open carrier delivery had a cracked windshield and scuffed bumper from the trip, which could've been me. Now I can't decide if I got lucky or if the enclosed route is just always worth it on older cars. Has anyone here shipped a car they actually cared about on an open carrier and come out fine?
Shipped a 20 year old truck on an open carrier once and it came through fine, but it was already a beater with faded paint so I wasn't sweating chips. The real factor is how much the driver cares and how loaded the truck is, and you can't control either one from a quote form. On a car with older repaint work I'd just pay for enclosed or skip the whole thing.