Tried a cheap tarp and a real car cover on my Miata for one winter in Buffalo, the difference was night and day
Last November I had to park my 2001 Miata outside for the first time because my garage got taken over by house stuff, and I tried a $20 blue tarp first since it was easy. Big mistake. The tarp trapped moisture underneath and by January I had condensation dripping off the inside of the windshield and a musty smell that took weeks to get out. Swapped to a $90 fitted cover from a brand I won't name and the difference was huge, mainly because it breathes and the elastic hem keeps it from flapping and rubbing the paint. The tarp also scratched the trunk lid where it whipped around in the wind, which I'm still a little mad about. I also put a couple of those moisture absorber tubs inside and dumped them once a month. The fitted cover let air move but kept rain and snow off, and the paint looked way better in March. If you're stuck storing outside for a season, spend a bit more on something that fits and breathes, in my experience. Anyone else have a tarp horror story or a cover that actually held up through a snowy winter?