I used to think paying $35 for a cereal mascot promo figure was dumb, then a guy at a flea market in Cleveland changed my mind | Cereal Mascot Talk - Chatter Central
I used to think paying $35 for a cereal mascot promo figure was dumb, then a guy at a flea market in Cleveland changed my mind
For years I laughed at people who dropped real money on cereal premium toys, like the old plastic Snap, Crackle and Pop figures or a boxed Quisp saucer. Last month at a flea market in Cleveland I saw a guy selling a 1990s Cornelius the Rooster PVC for $35 and I walked past it three times before I caved. Turns out that little rooster was part of a limited Kellogg's mail-in set from 1994, and once I got home and looked it up, the loose ones are going for $80 to $100 online. The guy even told me, "the mail-in stuff never got rerun, so it goes quick," and I sat there kicking myself for not grabbing the two others he had. I used to figure these things were just junk from a box, but now I see the mail-in mascots as the real collectibles because so few people kept the order forms. My $35 turned out to be the best money I spent all summer, and it made me rethink how I walk past bins at these markets. Does anyone here focus on mail-in premiums over the ones that came free in the box, and how do you tell the real ones from the reprints?
My uncle had a shoebox of old mail-in forms from the 80s he found in a house he bought, and half of them were for stuff I never even knew existed lol. I'd start by checking the stamp marks on the bottom of the figure against pics of mail-in ones, since the free in-box versions usually have a different mold line.