A 30-year finisher in Tulsa said my float work was too pretty, and I've been chewing on it since
Was grabbing a bite at a diner near a job in Tulsa and got to talking with a guy who's been finishing for three decades. He asked how I float and I said I take my time to get it real slick and flat. He laughed and said "slick don't hold nothing," that a slightly open, gritty finish gives the slab teeth for the next layer or the sealer. I had been babying my floats for years, proud of that glassy look. He explained he keeps a stiff float and works it just enough, maybe 2 or 3 passes, then stops. I tried it on a 400 sq ft driveway pour and the surface took a broom finish way better. Any of you guys keep it a little rougher on purpose, or am I the only one who always chased the pretty finish?