Hot take: that shiny wet sheen on your slab means nothing, and chasing it causes more problems than it fixes
I have watched three crews in the past month overwork their finish with extra passes chasing that mirror look, and every one of those driveways started hairline cracking within six weeks because they kept adding water and troweling past the point where the mix could take it, so I would rather finish to a flat, even matte and call it done than trade a pretty surface for cracks down the road, and I am curious whether anyone here has found a way to get both without beating up the mix.
Watching how you finish is the right call, but the sheen itself is not what causes the cracking. Cracks come from adding water and overworking the mix, which are two separate habits you can break without giving up a nice surface. Keep your water low, wait for the bleed water to leave, and use a proper trowel at the right time instead of extra passes to wet it back up. A hard trowel done once at the right moment gives you a tight, even surface without beating the mix to death, so you can have both if you watch the timing.