My 'kid-tested, dad-approved' joke flopped hard until I said it in a whisper

My wife told me my delivery was too shouty, so at the cookout on Sunday I tried the same pun about a broken pencil at a low volume and my nephew actually snorted. Anyone else find that whispering makes a bad dad joke 10 times funnier, or is my family just weird?

1 comments

1 Comment

stellachen20d ago

Wait, does the whisper trick work because it feels like a secret, or because it makes people lean in and actually listen for once? Because I tried that with my kids and it backfired spectacularly, they just thought I was telling them a secret about dessert and got mad when the punchline was about a vegetable. But here's the thing, my wife has this theory that dad jokes are like ASMR for dads, they only hit right when you're not trying to force the laugh out of someone. I did notice at my nephew's birthday that the quieter I got, the more the adults started shushing the kids just to hear the bad pun, which felt like a win even if the joke itself was terrible. Maybe the volume drop makes people feel like they're in on something, like a whispered insult about the neighbor's lawn that suddenly becomes hilarious. Or maybe your family is just weird, but in the best way, because mine definitely is and we've made whispering the default for all jokes now, even the good ones.