Rant: my brother told me my punchlines were too long and he counted, 14 words
My brother sat through my whole routine at a family BBQ in June and told me straight up that my setups were fine but every punchline ran 14 words or more. I argued with him for 10 minutes and then went home and timed myself out loud, and he was dead on. So I started cutting every joke down to the shortest possible punch and testing them on my coworkers at the office before posting anything here. Last week I posted a two-liner about a broken pencil and it got more votes than anything I wrote in the past 3 months. Turns out the pause after a short punch does all the work, and I was stepping on my own laughs the whole time. Now I keep a little notepad and strike out any word I don't need. Anyone else have someone call out their joke structure, and did it help or just make you second guess everything?