Showerthought: a librarian in Des Moines made me rethink how I judge AI writing tools
Last month I sat next to a librarian from Des Moines at a conference lunch, and she asked what I do with AI tools. When I said I use them to draft and edit writing, she said something that stuck: "A good tool should leave fingerprints you can live with, not erase yours." She explained that her library uses AI to tag old newspaper scans, but staff always check the tags by hand before they go live. That hit different because I had been chasing tools that made my drafts sound smoother, and smooth was the whole problem. Her point was that the machine should do the boring parts, like sorting and tagging, while a person keeps the voice. I went home and turned off the feature that rewrites my sentences, kept the one that just flags clunky grammar, and my drafts feel like mine again. Has anyone else drawn a hard line between what they let AI smooth over and what stays human, and where did you put it?